Ray Comfort made a short DVD response
to a popular atheist video on YouTube “Why Won't God Heal
Amputees.” This video is part of a website called www.whygodwonthealamputess.com
The DVD by Ray Comfort is 20 minutes
long.
The video is structured to be a
response to the atheist video, allowing it to provide its material
first. The atheist video begins by assuming the viewer is a smart,
educated person with a college degree who knows how to think
critically. Well in this case, Ray Comfort has no degree in science,
religion, history, or any other field. And as Ray's record has
revealed, he does not have a clue how to think rationally – in
fact, he discourages Christians from engaging in rational and
intellectual discussion and encourages Christians to instead appeal
to people's emotions.
First Question
Ray's Response: As a standard practice
of a manipulator to first flatter his hearers and then phrase his
questions so that it contains the answer that he wants. Like the old
“You're an intelligent lad, so answer me: Yes or no? Do you still
beat your mother.” So let's play this manipulative game for a
moment as we address the first question: why won't god heal amputees?
If you are an intelligent person, also ask yourself this question:
why won't god put money in the back accounts of the poor? That has
never happened, therefore god does not exist. Here is another one,
why hasn't god never grows new hair on bald men's heads? All balding
men pray for new hair, and you know that he completely ignores them,
therefore god does not exist. Here is some more, can god make a rock
that is too heavy for him to lift? Or can he make a square circle?
These are powerful intellectual arguments that prove to the
intelligent, thinking, clever, logical, rational, and educated mind
hat god doesn't exist. If however, after using such critical thinking
skills you conclude that he doesn't exist, you are left with
scientific impossibility of having the net belief that nothing
created everything. There is no alternative for the thinking person.
My response: Ray Comfort basically
shoots himself in the foot here he might as well be amputated. The
point of this questions was to show that if there is a god who
promises to respond to prayer, and yet ignores healing amputees (or
even feed the hungry or gives riches to the poor) then he is not a
good god – and according to Ray's Christianity, god is good by
definition. But this reveals god is not good, therefore there is no
god.
Last note, the alternative to there
being no god is not the view that “everything came from nothing.”
This is a deliberate straw-man Ray Comfort attributes to all atheists
– and every time he gets them to say they do not accept that, he
immediately responses with “so you believe that everything came
from something.” Lets address this now: another possible
alternative that Ray ignores is that perhaps the universe is eternal.
If God can be eternal, why not the universe (Occam's Razor would
agree with this). This point was brought up to Ray Comfort and his
sidekick Kirk Cameron in a debate with the Rational Response Squad –
to which he responded with complete silence, looking defeated.
Finally, the statement “so you
believe that everything came from something” is misleading because
it implies that everything CAME FROM X. He is merely asserting that
matter and energy had to come from somewhere, rather than think that
matter and energy did not come from anywhere and rather was always
here.
Second Question
Ray's Response: The second question,
why are there so may starving people in the world? Let's take that a
little further: why does so many children and adults get cancer and
die of other terrible disease? We are so many burned to death in
fires or crushed by earthquakes, die in tornadoes and hurricanes, are
killed by animals and even murdered by their own parents. So the
question becomes: if god exists and he good and loving, he would do
something about these terrible things. Well the book of Genesis gives
a perfectly rational explanation as to why all these things happen.
But that's in the Bible, and that is therefore inadmissible for a
thinking person. The conclusion: that god does not do anything to
stop evil or suffering and therefore he doesn't exist. Nothing
created everything.
My response: Ugh, read my first
response above.
Third Question
Ray's Response: The third question, why
dose god demand the death of so many innocent people in the Bible.
The answer: he doesn't demand the death of any innocent people. He
demands the death of guilty people. Not only in the Bible, but also
in this whole sinful world. We have all experienced the reality of
death because we are guilty of violating his moral law. We are also
told, among other things, that god demands that we kill these
disobedient teenagers. That is just not true (on screen he calls in a
straw-man). Why would anyone in today's society instigate the
three-thousand-year-old injunctions of Hebrew civil law. God demands
no such thing of any of us.
My response: “God demands no such
thing of any of us.” HELLO!!!!!! Ray just admitted this practice
was a “ three-thousand-year-old injunctions of Hebrew civil law”
which means this was indeed God DID demand us to do these horrible
things. Also, they were not Hebrew CIVIL laws, many of these are laws
by god himself. God himself in Exodus 21 orders the death to anyone
who works on the Sabbath (this was explained in the video) and yet
here is ray flat-out denying the plainly obvious before his eyes.
Fourth Question
Ray's Response: why does the Bible
contain so much anti-science nonsense? The answer: god supernaturally
created all things, and he therefore has the ability to suspend
natural law. He parts seas, walks on water, prepares the bellies of
whales, flood the earth which has ample empirical evidence (on screen
he shows a picture of the Grand Canyon), and rises the dead. With
god, nothing shall be impossible.
My response: First of all, so god makes
the earth flat and immobile, and yet Ray response he can do whatever
he wants? When did god make the earth orbit around the sun, the day
before we invented telescopes?
Second of all, there is ZERO evidence
for a global flood – Ray left no source nor provide any argument to
prove his case. All he did was show a picture of the Grand Canyon. There is nothing in the Grand Canyon to suggest a global flood. In fact, if there was a global flood, why the hell is there only one Grand Canyon?
How does one create 20 million annual
layers, each layer which would have taken at least a month to settle
due to hydrodynamics as is observed in the Green River Formation? How
does one explain seasonal of pollen grains found in the layers?
Why would there be Precambrian rocks
below ones feet in the Canadian Shield area, yet the entire geologic
column in the Williston Basin in North Dakota? Why would a global
flood scour down to the Precambrian in one place yet at the same time
deposit tens of thousands of feet of sediment in another when it is
exactly the same process? Giant post-pyramid ice ages are not an
explanation as there is no written record or other evidence of
increased historical glaciation to the extent needed to scour the
Canadian Shield down in the last 4500 years, not to mention such
Precambrian rocks elsewhere on Earth like South Africa.
Ice sheets & Ice caps can't reform
in the time allotted since any global flood of 4500 years ago.
The geologic record includes roughly 8
x 10E24 grams of lava flows and igneous intrusions. Assuming
(conservatively) a specific heat of 0.15, this magma would release
5.4 x 10E27 joules while cooling 1100 degrees C.
In
addition, the heat of crystallization as the magma solidifies would
release a great deal more heat.
Limestone formation: There
are roughly 5 x 10E23 grams of limestone in the earth's sediments
[Poldervaart, 1955], and the formation of calcite releases about
11,290 joules/gram [Weast, 1974, p. D63]. If only 10% of the
limestone were formed during the Flood, the 5.6 x 10E26 joules of
heat released would be enough to boil the flood waters.
Meteorite
impacts: Erosion and crustal movements have erased an unknown number
of impact craters on earth, but Creationists Whitcomb and DeYoung
suggest that cratering to the extent seen on the Moon and Mercury
occurred on earth during the year of Noah's Flood. The heat from just
one of the largest lunar impacts released an estimated 3 x 10E26
joules; the same sized object falling to earth would release even
more energy. [Fezer, pp.
45-46]
Other: Other possibly
significant heat sources are radioactive decay (some Creationists
claim that radioactive decay rates were much higher during the Flood
to account for consistently old radiometric dates); biological decay
(think of the heat released in compost piles); and compression of
sediments.
5.6 x 1026 joules is enough to heat the oceans
to boiling. 3.7 x 10E27 joules will vaporize them completely. Since
steam and air have a lower heat capacity than water, the steam
released will quickly raise the temperature of the atmosphere over
1000 C. At these temperatures, much of the atmosphere would boil off
the Earth.
Aside from losing its atmosphere, Earth can
only get rid of heat by radiating it to space, and it can't radiate
significantly more heat than it gets from the sun unless it is a
great deal hotter than it is now. (It is very nearly at thermal
equilibrium now.) If there weren't many millions of years to radiate
the heat from the above processes, the earth would still be unlivably
hot.
Fifth Question
Ray's Response: we tend to look at
slavery through the cruel American slave trade, where races of people
were kidnapped and sold for slaves. Kidnapping was a crime that the
god of the Bible considered to be so serious it was punishable by
death. Biblical slavery, that is bond-servant wasn't kidnapping and
it wasn't determined by skin color. Those who are in debt paid off
their debt through becoming a bond-servant. After six years, the
bond-servant was given his freedom. However, rather than have their
freedom, some would even chose to stay as bond-servants because
Hebrew law not only provided for them, it protected them legally. For
example, is a slave was mistreated and died at the hands of is
master, the master was to be put to death himself according to Exodus
21:20-21. The law of Moses did allow the use of enemy slave labor a
did civil law in American with German soldiers captured in WWII
(Source:http://mshistory.k12.ms.us/index/php?id=233).
My response: We do not look at slavery
through the perspective of the American slave trade. Slavery, in all
forms, is the complete ownership of another human being to be used as
tools.
Ray says the Bible protects slaves by punishing their masters if they killed their slaves. HOW THE HELL does this help? If the slave is dead, there is no protection. All that will follows is that there will be another dead corpse.
There is a lot more that Comfort did not mention regarding slavery. Leviticus 25:44-46, the Israelites were allowed to buy slaves from other nations, and then hand them down as an inheritance. In Leviticus 25:39 buying your brother as a slave is allowed. What we find appalling about slavery is the ownership of another human being, not just the mistreatment. What's more, not even Jesus was against slavery. He never said a word about slavery or how horrible it is. In fact, in Luke 12:45-48,
the Parable of the Faithful Servant, Jesus discusses the punishment of
slaves, and says that a slave may be punished for not doing something he
wasn't instructed to do.
Sixth Question
Ray's Response: God's definition of a
good person is someone who is morally perfect in thought, word and
deed – and only God is good. A more relevant question would be: why
do good things happen to bad people? The answer is that god lavished
his goodness upon us despite our may sins.
My response: So God allows goodness to happen to evil people? But supposedly we all get a share of this goodness? This is ridiculous. There are children born, and all they did in their very brief lives on this earth was starve. Where is the goodness in that? But rather, God sees fit to be good to bad people? lets not forget, whenever God wants he can punish a very good person just because he wants to (I am referring to Job).
Seventh Question
Ray's Response: what sort of evidence
should we expect to see from his walking on water or the feeding of
the 5,000 or the raising of the dead? Wet feet, bread crumbs or an
unreturned undertakers check? There is of course the real evidence of
eye-witness testimony. But that is in the Bible and it is therefore
inadmissible.
My response: We would indeed expect A
LOT of historical data from a village of 5,000 people being fed with
a few loafs.
As I discussed on my blog on the historicity of jesus, we should expect a lot of historical evidence for someone who claims to be soooooo popular that he followers from Jordan, entered the Temple on Passover and start a riot - AND YET not be mentioned one time. This, and more, gives credence to the liklihood that jesus never existed.
Eighth Question
Ray's Response: how do we explain the
fact that jesus has never appeared to you? These questions are
getting even weaker and a little weird.
My response: Ray did not even bother
answering the question. Cop-out.
Ninth Question
Ray's Response: when the Bible says
“and as they were eating, jesus took bread and blessed it and broke
it; and gave it to the disciples and said ''take, eat, this is my
body' he was physically with his disciples. They weren't eating him.
So any intelligent, educated, rational person would know that his
words were not disgusting, cannibalistic, satanic ritual. They were
symbolic, the wine and the bread were symbols and metaphors for his
blood and his body.
My response: My problem with this bit is - do we even know that jesus even said this, or that this Last Supper story even happened?
Tenth Question
Ray's Response: They don't! Skeptics
are continually saying that the church is filled with hypocrites and
this is proof that it is. A hypocrite is a pretender – that is a
fake christian. The Bible calls them goats that mix up with the
sheep, and god warns that he'll sort them out on the day of judgment.
And by the way, divorce is allowed for Christians if the spouse
commits adultery according to Matthew 19:9.
My response: So, the Bible allows
biblical divorce, and yet when Christians get divorced they are not
longer Christians!? Do you see the problem there?
According to Comfort, divorce is only allowed if the spouse committed adultery. But Comfort constantly states that any man who looks at a woman and lusts after her, he commits adultery in his heart. So one can argue that every case of Christian divorce could very well have been because someone was looking at some eye candy before they divorced - thereby making all Christian divorces following Matthew 19:9.
One last thing, lets look at 1 Corinthinians 7:15 "But if the unbelieving depart, let him depart. A brother or a sister is not under bondage in
such cases." So it seems divorce is also allowed in the 'unbelieving' spouse chooses to leave.
Bottoms line, divorce is allowed. Comfort contradicts himself when he stated that those who get divorced are fakers.
Conclusion
A presupposition for most of these 10
questions is that if god is good, he would heal amputees, feed the
starving, stop bad things happening, and not be a proponent of
slavery and he would do miracles when w tell him to. And the
conclusion that is because since he did not stop them or won't obey
us by performing miracles, he therefor does not exist. However, there
is one conclusion that which intelligent people should come when it
comes to god being good. If he truly is good, he must like a good
judge, see to it that ultimate justice is carried out. He must make
sure that murderers, rapists, thieves, liars, adulterers,
fornicators, and blasphemers are punished on judgment day. Judgment
day makes sense IF god is good to an intelligent educated person. In
conclusion, let me show you something remarkable. Some people believe
that god is imaginary. They imagine that he does not exist. And then
imagine that nothing created everything, and they say to themselves
“that makes complete sense, all scientific evidence supports this
conclusion.” That is called “delusionry.” As the Bible points
out, such people profess to be wise but they are fools. Rather than
following such illusionary thought,it would be wise to use our
god-given brain to say “hey, I am offered eternal life through the
gospel. An intelligent person would at least look into it.” So
please take the time to do that rather than listen to fools.
My response: Nobody in the video (not
even whywontgodhealamputees video) was asserting that the alternative
view that excludes god is that the universe must therefore come from
nothing. This is just dishonest Comfort asserting his twisted distorted strawman against atheism.
Atheists do not "image" that god does not exist no more than they imagine unicorns and red leprechauns don't exist. None of these don't exist BECAUSE THEY DON'T EXIST. Theists, like Ray Comfort, are the ones imagining that they do exist. Ray Comfort, through his entire evangelical career, has never presented any proof for God - and despite his whiny claims that he can prove God does exist, he knows he can't and he never has been able to prove his beliefs without invoking faith and wishful thinking based on presupposition arguments.
Extra: Street evangelism
For the last 5 or so minutes of the DVD,
Ray provides a clip of him witnessing to a person in Huntington
Beach. My responses will be in bold.
Starts off with Ray asking Jurgen if he
is a spiritual person, to which he answers “no I'm not.” Ray asks
him if he is an atheist, Jurgen says yes. Immediately Ray asks him “have you
ever heard of the Golden Rule?” Jurgen says no and asks Ray to
explain what it is. Ray says “you shall love your neighbor as you
love yourself.” Jurgen says he loves some of his neighbors, and
some he does not.
The golden rule is not "love your neighbor as yourself", its "don't do unto others as you would not have then do unto you." If comfort believes that the Golden rule is "love your neighbors as yourself" - that is actually a immoral position to hold. Imagine how Comfort's version of the Golden Rule would apply to sadomasochists? Also, if you love everyone willy-nilly, that actually demeans love.
Ray asks Jurgen why he is an atheist,
to which Jurgen replies with “because I don't believe in god.”
Immediately Ray responds with “so you believe nothing created
everything?” Jurgen replies that he believes in evolution. Ray asks
Jurgen “what created everything in the beginning?” Jurgen says he
was not there and therefore cannot answer. Ray responds with “well
it obviously wasn't nothing because nothing can't create anything. So
something created everything in the beginning.” Jurgen says “maybe”
to which Ray then says “so you are not an atheist. You believe
something created everything.” Jurgen replies he does not lose any
sleep trying to figure out who or what it was. Ray tells Jurgen he
should. Jurgen asks why? Ray answers “well because you have
offended him by sinned against his law.”
First of all, as I had already pointed out, atheism does not rest on the view that everything came from nothing - that is ray Comfort's twisted, distorted strawman he attributes to atheism. Atheism does not comment on the origins of anything, not even the universe. An atheist can hold any view he/she wishes, but they will not include a god.
Comfort's last statement that Jargen offended god is all based on Comfort's unsupported and baseless presupposition.
Ray then takes Jurgen down the are you
a good person? routine. Jurgen says he already heard Ray repeat this
close by and admits he had done some of the things Ray brings up.
Jurgen says everyone has lied or stolen, but when Jurgen asks when is
“judgment day” Ray replies with “it's coming. Sure as hell its
coming, God knows when its coming.” Jurgen says if Ray is talking
about his death, then Jurgen is assured that when he dies he will be
dead and that's that. Ray asks “what if you're wrong?” to which
Jurgen says “then so be it.” Ray asks Jurgen “do you care about
your life?” When Jurgen says yes, Ray replies “Jesus said what
shall profit a man if he gains the whole world but loses his own
soul?”
Ray tells Jurgen he does not want him
to end up in hell, “you seem like a nice guy, I would hate god to
give you what you deserve – you're a lying thief blasphemer and an
adulterer at heart.” Jurgen does not seem to take any interest and
replies with “whatever will happen will happen. As they say
sura-sura.” Ray replies “that's a song, that's Hollywood. You do
not want to put your faith in Hollywood and love songs, c'mon. You
want to put your faith in the savior because he can wash away your
sins so you'll be clean on judgment day and god can let you live
forever.” Jurgen asks “who want's to live forever?” to which
Ray responds with “well I do.”
NO ONE deserves an infinite punishment for a finite crime, that is the apotheosis of immorality. Comfort does not care about Jargen nor does Jargen done anything to deserve such baseless threats of damnation. Shame on Ray Comfort.
How is quoting a song an implication of faith? if a person quotes a line from the Beatles, they are not putting their faith in the Beatles, just repeating the words because words by themselves contain truth. Based on Comfort's reaction, and quickly whining at Jargen seems to me imply that Comfort knows he is playing a dishonest game here.
One last thing, Ray if you want to live forever, then you truly have never lived for a day have you?
Ray asks Jurgen how old he is (68) and
how long does he think he is going to live (20 or so more years). Ray
asks Jurgen if he is afraid of dying, to which Jurgen answers “no,
if someone told me you have one more month to live, I would says okay
I have lived a full life with few regrets, so I'm ready to go.” Ray
asks “so you wouldn't have any treatment if you learned you had
cancer? You would just yield to it?” Jurgen shows a scar from a
recent surgery (he had a clogged artery). Ray says “hang on, you
just said that you would not mind dying. You should have just put up
with it and died.” Jurgen said it was not as severe as cancer, but
Ray interrupts and states “yeah, but you let a person you don't
know cut into your chest so you could live longer.” Jargen said he
had to have the surgery because it would have prevented him from
living life the fullest as he desired (running, physically active,
etc). Ray asks “so you are thankful for a healthy life?” Jurgen
says “yeah” but Ray immediately asks “who to?” Jurgen says he
is thankful for himself being physically active, but Ray cuts him off
“yeah, but who are you grateful to for a healthy life? God gave you
life!” Jurgen replies with “maybe so, you can't prove that
anymore than I can.” Ray responds “yes I can! You can't say I
can't, because I can!”
First of all, as Jargen already shared he is not afraid to die. Jargen loved to stay fit and healthy to lavish in the joys of this life. Cancer or heart problems would have prevented him to continue on living as he wished. Comfort, on the other hand, thinks all credibility for anything enjoyable goes to god. But when Jargen demands Comfort to prove it, Comfort gives Jargen nothing, as we will see in a moment...
Jurgen aks Ray to prove it. This is
Ray's response: “all you have to do is do what the Bible says;
repent and trust in him who died on the cross for you. If you'll do
that, if you repent and trust in the savior and say 'god forgive my
sins' and willfully put your trust in jesus christ, god will reveal
himself to you. This is what jesus said: he who has my commandments
and keeps them, adheres and loves me and he who loves me will be
loved by my father, I too will love him and will reveal myself to
him. So there is the gauntlet – if you obey the gospel, god will
reveal himself to you.”
This is basically the worst response ever. A Muslim can do the same thing - seek allah and you will find him. What Comfort fails to understand was the same result can be achieved for those who seek out ghosts, aliens, Bigfoot,
or any deity "with their whole heart", meaning they have already
assumed these things exist without question or prior evidence that they
exist in the first place.
Jurgen responds with “are you
compelled to do any other thing you desire?” Ray responds with
“well let me leave the ball in your court, and maybe tonight you
might have a minor heart attack in your bed and you'll think about
the issues of life and death, and your desire to get right with god
before death ceases upon me – because this is so important
remember, jesus said 'what shall profit a man if he gained the whole
world but loses his very own soul.' Jurgen thank you for talking to
me, I really appreciate it.” Jargen says “you're welcome, have a
good day.” The clip ends with this note: while riding his bike on
December 23, 2010 at 5:35 pm, Jurgen Akenbrad was struck by one
vehicle, and then run over by another. He was pronounced dead at the
scene. He was 69 years old (they reply the bit where Jurgen says he
is 68 and thinks he has another 20 years to live).
Condolences to Jargen and his mourning family. Unfortunately for Ray, Jargen did not lose his soul. Nobody has a soul to lose, not even Ray Comfort.
In this book, Ray Comfort hopes (and
fails) to provide a case that the existence of God can be proven
scientifically. Throughout the book, he repeats many of his old
arguments that are known to be flawed and refuted a thousand times.
Comfort further displays a great lack
of understanding of science throughout the book. He bashes and
targets atheism and evolution, as if disproving one position makes
his win by default. Evolution does not disprove God; many Christians
accept evolution and believe in God. Evolution, however, does
contradict and refute a literal interpretation of the book of
Genesis, and this is precisely what Ray Comfort is defending;
creationism. Creationism is the position that everything was created
by God out of thin air from nothing. The book of Genesis has God
saying "Let there be..." and there was and it was good.
This is a form of an incantation (i.e. MAGIC), and thus Comfort is
arguing for a supernatural position with science, but it is clear
science cannot prove the supernatural.
Ray Comfort, in this book title, is
implying we can “know” god exists. However, knowledge is
demonstratable. If you claim to know something you can empirically
demonstrate it to the rest of us. For instance, I know if I take off
my hat and drop it, it will fall to the ground every time I repeat
this. If Ray Comfort knows there is a god (which I doubt) then he
should be able to demonstrate it to us. Spoiler: all it boils down to
is blind faith.
Chapter 1: Are Atheists Smarter than Most?
Comfort starts off by telling a story of his wife and a series of events in his life. One of these includes accidentally walking into a room with a couple in their underwear. Based on this, Comfort calls himself a klutz, but could a klutz make a case against evolution?
Actually, Comfort, the correct question
would be whether if a scientific-illiterate willfully ignorant
deceiver can make any case against the strongest scientific theory in
modern science.
Ray Comfort has desperately tried to
make a case against evolution, one being the banana. Ray was utterly
refuted and humiliated, and tried to weasel out of his error and
digging himself deeper into a hole. The moral of the story is; this
klutz has no chance in making a case against evolution.
Second of all, if Ray Comfort could
make a solid case against evolution (which he never did or could),
that would not prove his god. The title of the book is “How to Know
God Exists” - rather than addressing atheology or the like, he
resorts to bashing a scientific theory instead of providing positive
evidence that god exists. If evolution were false, that would not
make the god hypothesis win by default. Use your imagination, life
could have been made by time-travelers. There are many other
possibilities to how life could have started – I firmly accept the
reality that the mythical fables of Genesis or creationism is not one
of the possibilities of how life could have started. The point is,
Ray Comfort and swing at any number of the other natural scenarios of
the origin of life, but he does not provide any positive evidence for
his god in return.
Comfort outlines that if there is no God, then the only purpose in life is pleasure. However, if there is a God, then we are morally obliged to him.
This is incorrect. A world in which no
gods exist (which is this the case for our present reality) does not
mean we exclude what we are: we are communal animals. In Ray
Comfort's mind, he thinks that we would just act like animals and our
world will basically be Sodom and Gomorrah.
What is the purpose of life without a
God? How about simply living and experience? What would be the point
of life if the purpose of it was not to live? How you live your life
is another story. Some could devote their entire lives to meditation
and selflessness.
If there is a god, why would we be
morally obliged to him – especially if it gave us free will? I do
not have children, but if I had a child, it would never cross my mind
that my child is forever bound to my will. Anyone who has a child
knows that eventually you cannot hold onto them forever and one day
they will be set free.
Mr. Joe Average
Comfort creates a character Joe Average, a typical atheist or agnostic.
With this hypothetical creation,
Comfort creates a fictional character whose intellect and knowledge
is limited and restricted entirely by Comfort's will (i.e. Ray is
crafting a strawman to his liking), and will likely make Joe Average
give the type of “critical” responses that Comfort will easily
break down. This will make Joe Average, the atheist, seem on a lower
level of intelligence than Ray Comfort. Rather than sharing an actual
conversation with a thinking being, Ray Comfort resorts to
imagination. (In fact, whenever Ray has a conversation with a
thinking atheist, he never makes a solid case for his god).
Joe does not think about creation (perhaps, Comfort, it is because he knows there is no creation), but Comfort says Joe's body is a miracle machine. Comfort compares it to a robot built in Japan. The differences between the two is that Joe has certain senses and can walk upright without someone holding it up. Comfort goes into detail of the human anatomy and concludes this could only be the work of a designer.
The human body is not a “miracle
machine.” It is a natural biological product that formed through
natural processes via natural selection.
Mankind has given robots certain
senses, such as light-sensitivity, movement sensors, and such. Recent
robots have been manufactured to walk, dance, and perform tricks
without a human holding it.
Comfort here is resorting to the whole
“the body looks complex, it must have a designer.” What Ray has
failed to do is actually provide positive evidence that it was
specifically designed. Unfortunately for Ray, all these “complex
details” of the human anatomy is the result of evolution – which
we can prove and has been proven.
Comfort goes on to look closely at Joe's life at breakfast, and how everything he eats came from a living creature. Joe then examines his environment with his senses, which Comfort always calls "God-given." When asked to provide proof that God created the cow that produced the butter for Joe's toast, Comfort challenges anyone to create a cow from nothing.
Our senses are not “God-given” for
the simple fact that there is no proof that any god exists. With no
god, there are no “god-given” whatevers. For the sake or
argument, lets say there is some supreme being, for all we know Ray
Comfort cannot prove that its actually Krishna or something similar.
All he can do is resort to blind faith in a man-made book written by
superstitious Bronze-Age men.
“Create a cow from nothing” –
Comfort knows what he is demanding is completely ridiculous and
unobtainable – in all honesty, this demand is very immature and
intellectually-free.
Comfort is the one who is defending
magical creation, thus it is he who has to provide empirical proof of
creation and present that some material can be created from nothing.
We’ve never seen anything “created”. No
one has ever seen a complex life-form (or anything else) magically
pop out of thin air – violating the conservation of matter. But
that’s what creationists are arguing for! Talismans, incantations,
elemental component spells, enchantments, clairvoyance and prophesies
all consistently fail every test. Yet, creationists like Ray Comfort
still boost that their favorite fable character conducted a magical
incantation and SPOKE everything into being out of nothing. Their
position willingly violates the conservation of matter, inserts the
untestable magical-supernatural realm, and yet they have the gall to
say “I don't have to prove it, rather YOU cannot create X out of
nothing, therefor I win.”
Comfort provides a poll from 2007 that 91 percent of the American population believes in God. Comfort questions if this minority is smarter than the majority. Comfort defines an atheist as "someone who believes there is no God."
However, a recent poll shows it is
close to 80%, another showing 36% of the country are non-religious.
This is not necessarily correct, an
atheist may be someone who does not believe in god, but more commonly
it is a person who lacks belief in a God (any god, not just Comfort's
god). Just as a person lacks a belief in the Mystical
Mind-Controlling Squid living on Pluto, no one would argue they
''believe'' he does not exist, they are just unconvinced that he does
exist.
Are minorities smarter than the
majority? They very well can be. In much of the world, even people
who accept evolution and a natural origin for stars and worlds are a
minority. How likely is it that non-creationists are right when so
much of the world is wrong? Of course, this argument has its
problems: four hundred years ago, heliocentrists were a minority.
Evidence, not mere numbers giving uninformed assent, is relevant
here. Comfort varies the appeal to the wisdom of the masses with an
appeal to the wisdom of geniuses: Einstein, he assures us, believed
in God. Not necessarily a personal God, not a God Who inspired an
inerrant Holy Bible, and especially not a God Who judged and forgave
us, but Something that Einstein thought was not quite the same as the
universe itself (Einstein did not want to call himself a pantheist).
Oddly, Comfort doesn't present us with Einstein's arguments for God
(or perhaps this is not so odd, as Einstein didn't actually present
such arguments), but appeals to the authority of cosmologists as he
appeals to the authority of popular opinion.
Comfort ends this section by saying that there is proof of God and his existence can be proven.
We have heard that one before Comfort, even many times from you. Comfort proposed that he could prove the existence of God on Nightlinewith a debate with the Rational Response Squad without invoking faith or the Bible (spoiler: that did not happen and Comfort failed to prove God).
The Sciences
Comfort first notes that the reader should keep an open mind throughout the book.
This is coming from a guy who refuses to even consider the actual evidence science presents. Comfort says that no theory claims to have absolute truth, which is actually correct. However, this honesty is short-lived. Comfort says science is constantly refining what a theory is. The more appropriate word is update when new data is collected, but if a model no longer provides a provable explanation for things, a new model replaces it. The various models within evolution have changed over the last 150 years, and are at times the topic of serious debate between evolutionary biologists, however, the basic theory that life has evolved from one or a few common ancestors has not changed, and we continue to find evidence that support evolution and we observe speciation today.
Comfort says God's existence can be proven in the following fields of science,
*Physical sciences (physics)
*Earth sciences (the structure and compositions of earth)
*Life sciences (biology)
Comfort says the origin of the word "science" comes from the Latin word ''scientificus'' which means "producing knowledge."
This is incorrect. Science actually comes from the Latin word ''scientia'', meaning "knowledge."
What Ray does not understand is that science makes no comment on the supernatural, and thus all of Comforts "sciences" above will be futile in proving the existence of God.
Comfort's first proposed evidence for the existence of God is the Anthropic principle.
This principle is defeated simply because it is a tautology, weakened by the fact of quantum mechanics and the multiverse. The Copernican Principle is more accurate. The Copernican Principle is the opposite of the Anthropic Principle and states that humans do not occupy a privileged place in the universe. Successive astronomical discoveries seem to support this principle. The Anthropic Principle emphasizes the rarity of life and consciousness while the Copernican Principle forces us to realize it was not all done just so we could exist.
According to Comfort, there are three types of knowledge that each can prove the existence of God,
*Intellectual knowledge
*Subconscious knowledge
*Experiential knowledge
The first evidence for God, Comfort will examine is "creation" in the next section.
Millions of Years
Comfort begins this section with his Coca-cola can analogy
This is a straw-man of the Big Bang Theory. Comfort's analogy is not even a hypothesis. This is how it goes: there was nothing, which exploded and produced everything. Over billions of years, a big rock forms. On top of this rock forms a muddy puddle, from which metal arises. Then red and white paints fall from the sky and land on the metal, so accurately it forms words and pattens. And thus, the modern Coke can is formed. The response Comfort provides is that his analogy is ridiculous. Comfort tries to turns the table by saying: we know the coke can had a maker, to believe it formed on its own by random chance is too move into an intellectual-free zone. By this logic, does lightning have a lightning maker? What about the patterns we see in snowflakes and crystals, and yet we know for a fact they form from natural forces. If we accept the idea that everything must have a creator, Comfort fails to provide any proof that the creator is his narrow concept of God, or if it is even his God or multiple Gods, or even aliens, gnomes, or the Flying Spaghetti Monster.
Comfort calls this analogy a "parody of evolution."
However, this is not a parody, it is a straw man, and it is not even about evolution. As explained to Comfort many times, evolution is not connected to Cosmology or Abiogenesis. Whenever the term evolution is applied in these fields it simply means "change over time." At all times, everything is subject to change. The Big Bang Theory does not say everything came from nothing, creationism does.}}
Comfort moves on from the Coke can and mentions on his show Way of the Master that Comfort used this argument along with another analogy using the banana.
The banana fallacy is exactly what got
Ray Comfort his nickname (Banana-man) when awareness of his existence
skyrocketed amongst the atheist and skeptic community, and in return
criticism soared through the Internets utterly refuting his argument
and handing his ass back to him. Ray Comfort suffered a great deal of
humiliation. First he tried to deny he made the banana argument,
claiming it was a hoax created by atheists. When that lie was
exposed, he even had to publish an “apology” video and
acknowledged the fact that the yellow banana is in fact a product of
evolution.
It is also very funny that many people
outside the atheist and skeptic community know of the banana argument
and how ridiculous it is (I've personally met dozens and dozens) but
they have never heard of Ray Comfort.
Comfort appeals to authority by quoting Sir Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein as men who believed there was a Creator. While Ray admits that Einstein did not believe in a personal God, Ray tries to portray him in that sort of life, such as by quoting friends of Einstein who viewed Einstein as a "disguised theologian." The reason why they accepted a creator, according to Ray, was because they could see order and design in the universe.
Neither of these points present a shred
of proof for a creator. We may seen design in the universe, but that
does not mean the universe as a whole was designed. For instance, we
see very complex design and distinct patterns in snowflakes and
crystals, but they both form naturally without any interference of a
designer.
We also see massive amounts of
non-design and disorder in the universe, which could be argued to
disprove an intelligent designer, or at least present a legitimate
argument that the universe cannot be the result of design.
Comfort uses his old arguments that a building had a builder and a painting had a painter, similarly creation proves there is a creator. Comfort says you do not need faith to believe in a creator, you just need eyes that can see and a brain that works.
As already pointed out to him, in a debate with the Rational Response Squad and many others, we can prove that a building had a builder. We can contact the engineer, cities parking structure, the electrician, and others. We can do the same with a painting, we can contact the canvas maker, the paint maker, the artist, etc. However, we cannot contact God to take us to his "creation factory." This point was pushed onto Ray Comfort
and Kirk Cameron, to which they had no response to provide – and
YET they were the ones who claimed they could prove their god
scientifically without invoking faith or the Bible. The ONLY reason
why Ray Comfort labels the universe a creation is because of Genesis.
One other point, can we prove a
building without a builder? I respond, why limit this to a building?
How about a bridge. Can anyone prove a bridge without a bridge maker?
May sound just as unlikely as the building, but nope. In fact, there
are hundreds of examples in nature were bridges form naturally
without a bridge maker. Simple good "natural arch."
(As far as I know, I am the one who came
up with this bridge argument. In all my research into Ray Comfort and
all his critics, I could not find a single reference to bridges or
anything similar – but I admit I could be mistaken and someone out
there beat me to the punch.)
The reason why his creation requires a creator argument fails is that Ray, basing his views on a presupposition, is merely assume everything as a creation and labeling it so. Simply labeling something does not change its character or its origin. Ray says that accepting his "creation requires a creator" argument is "logical, reasonable, and scientific."
First of all, this argument begs the question of which creator? Ray cannot provide any tests to point that the creator is his narrow version of a creator and not some invisible sky pixie, the Flying Spaghetti Monster, or multiple creators. The reason why his argument is not reasonable or logical is because it has no evidence to support itself, contains several logical fallacies, and it breaks down the moment you bring God into question. Ray says God did not have a creator, so then why can't energy have no creator? The law of physics already states that energy cannot be created, and matter is composed of energy, so therefore the universe does not require a creator nor did it come from "nothing." The reason why Ray's argument is not scientific is because he has not and cannot provide any empirical data or falsifiable tests to prove that there is a creator(s). During a debate with the Atheist Experience, Ray admitted that all the testing that is requires is "common sense." This, of course, is ludicrous. Common sense at one point told us that the earth was fixed and stationary and all other objects orbited around our planet. However, as new data was collected and tests were done, we learned that what we previously once believed was not true. Everything we have learned about our universe does not hint or provide any reason that our universe was the product of some divine creation. Science has proven that our universe can arise naturally without any supernatural intervention.}}
Chapter 2: Absurd in the Highest Degree
Based on the heading of this chapter,
anyone familiar with the creation vs. science debate knows where this
is going. This chapter mainly addresses intelligent design and the
human eye. Ray Comfort goes into detail about how marvelous the eye
is, how fast blinking is, the light sensitive cells, sight, etc. He
has repeated this argument many times, but nitpicking bits of the
human body is rather pointless. Comfort has used this argument many
times, and it is still unconvincing as ever. What he does not include
is the flaws in the human eye, such as a blind spot (Ray Comfort
outright denies we have blind spots), or that images are sent to our
brains backwards and upside down.
Moving on, Comfort
includes several quote mines; most notable is the one from Charles
Darwin.
"To suppose that the eye, with all its inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to different distances, for admitting different amounts of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic aberration, could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest possible degree."
The quote from Darwin above is taken out of context and is a common piece of dishonest creationist propaganda. Here is the full paragraph with the omitted section in bold,
"To suppose that the eye, with all its inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to different distances, for admitting different amounts of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic aberration, could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest possible degree. Yet reason tells me, that if numerous gradations from a perfect and complex eye to one very imperfect and simple, each grade being useful to its possessor, can be shown to exist; if further, the eye does vary ever so slightly, and the variations be inherited, which is certainly the case; and if any variation or modification in the organ be ever useful to an animal under changing conditions of life, then the difficulty of believing that a perfect and complex eye could be formed by natural selection, though insuperable by our imagination, can hardly be considered real. How a nerve comes to be sensitive to light, hardly concerns us more than how life itself first originated; but I may remark that several facts make me suspect that any sensitive nerve may be rendered sensitive to light, and likewise to those coarser vibrations of the air which produce sound.
Darwin continues with three more pages describing a sequence of plausible intermediate stages between eyelessness and human eyes, giving examples from existing organisms to show that the intermediates are viable. Scientists have shown that these stages did indeed happen through natural selection.
Besides the eye, Comfort focuses special attention on the ear and the nose.
Both bear vestiges of an evolutionary history, supported by the fossil record (as seen in the transition from reptile to mammal). Not much complexity is needed for a functional ear. All that is necessary is a nerve connected to something that can vibrate. Insects have evolved "ears" on at least eleven different parts of their bodies, from antennae to legs (Hoy and Robert 1996). Even humans detect very low frequencies via tactile sensation, not through their ears
Comfort ends the chapter by arguing that we don't need faith to know that God exists, because the Bible declares that God's existence is obvious from evidence.
This is obviously not true. If the evidence for God was obvious, then the matter would have been settled way before the Greek philosophers. God, as described by theists, keeps changing over the years as new data is collected. Presently, God as described by theists does not agree with the current data.
1. A God who is responsible for the complex structure of the world, especially living things, fails to agree with empirical fact that this structure can be understood to arise from simple natural processes and shows none of the expected signs of design. Indeed, the universe looks as it should look in the absence of design.
2. A God who has given humans immortal souls fails to agree with the empirical facts that human memories and personalities are determined by physical processes, that no nonphysical or extraphysical powers of the mind can be found, and that no evidence exists for an afterlife.
3. A God who miraculously and supernaturally created the universe fails to agree with the empirical fact that no violations of physical law were required to produce the universe, its laws, or its existence rather than nonexistence. It also fails to agree with established theories, based on empirical facts, which indicate that the universe began with maximum entropy and so bears no imprint of a creator.
4. A God who communicates directly with humans by means of revelation fails to agree with the fact that no claimed revelation has ever been confirmed empirically, while many have been falsified. No claimed revelation contains information that could not have been already in the head of the person making the claim.
Simply quoting a man-made book that the
evidence for X is obvious and everyone knows the proof for X is
self-evident is, again, pointless. People can use any number of
sacred texts that make that exact same argument. Labeling the
evidence for X is obvious and running around willy-nilly as if you
accomplished something is immature and self-defeating.
Chapter 3: Is Evolution Scientific?
The first line of this chapter says "The foundation of atheism is the theory of evolution."
Comfort is completely wrong, and he knows it.
Atheism does not require acceptance of evolution, or vice-versa. Many
Christians accept evolution, and some atheists do not. Evolution does
not refute God.
The mere fact that atheism predate the
theory of evolution disproves Comfort ridiculous and thoughtless
claim.
The early
pioneers of evolutionary science were all initially Christian,
(including Darwin) and many leading proponents of modern evolutionary
science are still Christian today. For example, microbiologist Dr.
Ken Miller, (who testified against intelligent design creationism in
Kitzmiller v. Dover) -is a Catholic. Another outspoken proponent of
evolution, Dr. Robert T. Bakker, (who has PhDs from both Harvard and
Yale) is not only one of the leading, and most recognizable
paleontologists in the world today, but he also happens to be a
Bible-believing Pentecostal preacher; though he interprets Genesis
differently than literalists would. In his book, Bones,
Bibles and Creation, he says that to
treat the Bible as though it were common history is to degrade its
eternal meaning. One of the earliest geneticists, Theodosius
Dobzhansky was an Orthodox Christian who many times professed his
belief that life was created by God, but that nothing in biology made
sense except in light of evolution. All these men agree that even if
there really is a god, and even if that god is the Christian god, and
even if that god created the universe and everything in it, -which
they all believe- evolution would still be at least mostly true, and
creationism would still be completely wrong.
This chapter focuses on whether evolution is not only a fact, but also scientific. Comfort includes a quote that explains evolution is a historical science and we search for fossils to fit the theory. It also states evolution cannot be directly tested. Comfort argues that none of us were there at the beginning, but if we want to prove evolution is true with historical evidence, we should find evidence for the following:
*How the universe began
*How life began
*How we have such diversity of life
All of these, according to Comfort, should have evidence of random causes and natural explanations.
First of all, in order to find
historical proof for the theory of evolution, finding answers for how
the universe or life began IS NOT RELEVANT. The theory of evolution
is only focused on the diversity of life, not how everything began.
This would be like trying to find the answers to how a star forms in
order to prove how germs cause diseases. The two are completely
unrelated and lack of evidence for one does not damage the other.
Second of all, evolution is not a
historical science. Evolution is happening right now, just as it
always has since the dawn of life. Imagine is Ray Comfort was arguing
the theory of heliocentrism is a historical science – trying to
find historical proof that the earth orbits around the sun. This
would completely ignore the undeniable fact that the Earth is
presently orbiting about the sun right now. Or how about arguing
plate tectonics, the theory of how the geological plates move, is a
historical science. Not only is this not the case, but it also is
missing the point that the plates continue to move right now.
Third, Comfort mistakenly assumes is
that the origin of the universe, life and diversity of life all must
be "random." They are not. Natural Selection is not a
random system. Evolution does depend on
mutations, and these do appear to be random. But each cumulative
mutation may become significant factors for that organism once pitted
against the dynamics of the environment in which they are introduced.
Thus natural selection isn’t random; it’s deterministic. Many
creationists will even admit this. And as some computer models have
already shown, natural selection can actually even exceed the skills of human
designers. In fact, natural selection can be so deterministic that it
often leads to innovations which some perceive as evidence of
intelligent design, and which even rationalists describe as though
modified for intended benefit.
It has been pointed out to Comfort that
evolution does not comment or even try to prove the origin of the
universe or life. This is an old creationist straw man of what
evolution actually explains. Evolution is not random, as Comfort
constantly tries to label it. Evolution can be and has been tested
countless times. Also, the "were you there?" argument
fails, because we have visual images of fossils and evolution
continues to this day (speciation). However, we were not there to
witness creation or the birth of Jesus.
Origin of the Universe
Comfort argues that people do not accept God because they cannot comprehend an eternal being, but they will accept what scientists tell them; that the universe is eternal. Comfort says if you accept an eternal universe, it is "logically" possible to accept an eternal being like God.
What Comfort is careful not to include is Occam's Razor that refutes the concept of an eternal being who created the universe.
If theists claim their God is eternal,
why can't the universe be eternal?
A) The universe was created by a god
who is uncreated and eternal
B) The universe is uncreated and
eternal
Occams Razor rules out a god creator,
because it unlocks hundreds of new questions (that are mostly
unanswerable and untestable). Occams Razor would say, just say a step
and settle with an uncreated universe. This has been pointed out to him during a debate with the Rational Response Squad,
which left him and Kirk Cameron
completely speechless with no counter argument to present – despite
being asked TWICE to present a counter-argument. All they did was sit
in their chairs with dumbstruck expressions with nothing to counter
Occams Razor with.
Also, just merely conceiving an eternal
thing does not mean all eternal concepts exist in reality. People can
comprehend and conceive a unicorn, but that does not mean unicorns
exist in reality.
Finally, it is completely acceptable
that the universe is eternal, but Comfort argues therefore it should
be logical to accept an “eternal being like God.” Despite being
refuted by Occams Razor, is it still possible to believe in an
eternal being like God? I would argue 100% NO. By the same logic by
Ray Comfort, if you accept the universe is eternal, you should
logically therefore accept the possibility of eternal beings like
Vishnu or Krishna. I can already see Ray Comfort waving his hands
around saying “no, no, no, no!” Unfortunately for Ray, yes, yes
yes. Theoretically, you can imagine an infinite number of eternal
beings that could exist. The problem is this: the laws of physics
already show that matter cannot be created, while on the other hand
we do not have any proof whatsoever for any eternal god-like beings.
Thus far in this book, and rather throughout Ray Comfort's religious
career, he has not presented a single shred of proof for his
particular god.
Comfort goes on to explain scientists have proven the universe had a beginning. Comfort brings up the question "Who created God?" but dances around it and does not answer it. Next he addresses the Big Bang Theory, which Comfort claims says everything came from nothing.
This dead horse is taking a hefty
beating. The Big Bang does not say the universe came from nothing;
creationism does.
The Big Bang does not prove the
universe had a beginning, just the start of time in this universe,
but the theory does not hold that everything had a beginning. The
laws of physics state that matter cannot be created. The Big Crunch
could explain that the universe is in a constant cycle of expanding
and shrinking. All the matter in the universe operates like a great
heart beat. All the matter is condensed to this one spot due to
gravity, becomes unstable and breaks apart and expands outwards,
until gravity pulls it all back in. Then repeat and repeat. Based on
this, the Big Bang does not say that everything came from nothing,
because all the matter in the universe was already here.
Comfort firmly believes the evidence (which he does not source) says the universe is not eternal and must have had a beginning. The two dilemmas set forth by Comfort are 1) where did matter come from and 2) what caused it to go "bang"?
However, these are not dilemmas at all. Matter is made of energy, which did not have to come from anywhere. What caused it to go bang? It became unstable.
Comfort quotes cosmologist Andrei Linde, professor of physics and Standford University,
"The first, the main, problem is the very existence of the big bang. One may wonder, what came before? If space-time did not exist then, how could everything appear from nothing? What arose first? The universe or the laws determining its evolution? Explaining this initial singularity—where and when it all began—still remains the most intractable problem of modern cosmology"
Comfort uses his coke can argument, arguing that if people find it nonsense then how is the Big Bang any more scientific?
The difference is that the Big Bang has evidence to support it and it has provided powerful predictions that have been proven true. Comfort's coke can argument has none of the above, it is rather a straw man argument of what the Big Bang Theory actually proposes.
However, Comfort concludes that no matter what, we all must accept the "logical, reasonable, and scientific" conclusion: a uncaused cause. Comfort argues that there has never been an instance when something has come from nothing; such an occurrence is un-scientific.
Comfort has it completely back-asswards. Not once in this section (or entire chapter) has Comfort provided studies, peer reviewed work, or predictions that can be falsified so this is not scientific. It is not logical or reasonable since there is no evidence to support it and its foundation breaks apart from what we have actually discovered about the universe and when you compare the same logic to God. Once the same arguments and logic is used for God, then it just vanishes. If God can be uncaused, then so could the universe. What Comfort is aiming for is a god of the gaps fallacy.
Comfort provides a quote from Charles Darwin seeming to agree that there must have been a first cause and that cause was God.
"The impossibility of conceiving that this grand an wondrous universe, with our conscious selves, arose through chance, seems to me the chief argument for the existence of God...I am aware that if we admit a first cause, the mind still craves to know whence it came and how it arose."
Next, Comfort quote-mines Stephen Hawking to give the appearance that he and Einstein agreed that the universe appears fine-tuned.
In conclusion, Comfort argues that evolution cannot account for the origin or complexity of the universe and the only options are 1) no one created everything out of nothing or 2) someone (an intelligent, omnipotent, eternal First Cause) created everything from nothing.
However, Comfort's points are not just fallacious; they are dishonest. Evolution, by its nature, plays no role whatsoever in cosmology, chemistry, physics, or any other field outside of biology. When evolution is used in the context of explaining things in space, it simple means "change over time," not the biological definition of explaining diversity and speciation.
For the sake of argument, if Comfort's position and presupposition of a first cause is examined, it turns out to be incorrect. First, it begs the question because it does not name or identify who the creator is, so it could not be the Christian God but instead an invisible sky pixie or the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Ignoring the Christian god is not powerful enough to stop chariots of iron in Judges 1:19, the cosmos encompasses all the mass/energy available anywhere. If God possesses energy that not only created but also interacts with the material world, then, by definition, he is part of the natural universe or the universe is part of him (which is the same thing). Whatsoever God’s source of energy might be, it exists somewhere, adding to the size of the cosmos. An omnipotent God would make the cosmos infinitely massive, a fact that is contradicted by the expansion of the universe (or, if God is outside our own pocket universe, by the uniformity of such expansion), or by the fact that we are not all instantly compressed by the gravity of infinite matter or incinerated with heat by being in the presence of such a grotesquely massive black hole out there. Whenever God, who must be infinitely massive, interacts with the universe or reaches into this pocket universe) and performs miracles, by the law of gravity and attraction, all the finite matter in the universe would be sucked in by this infinite mass. This means that it is impossible for God to perform miracles such as virgin births or parting the sea.
Origin of Life
Comfort argues that evolutionists must explain the origin of life because evolution requires non-life becoming life.
However, this is incorrect. Evolution only explains the diversity of life, not the origin of life itself. How life started is irrelevant to evolution, because once life formed evolution kicks in.
What is very interesting, why do
creationists continue to insist that the theory of evolution explain
the origin of life. Cell theory states that all living things are
made of cells. AND YET, creationists do not raise any objections
towards Cell Theory because it does not explain how the first
cell formed.
Comfort argues Louis Pasteur's Law of Biogenesis which disproves "spontaneous generation" that life can come from non-life.
Bollocks. Pasteur's Law does not
disprove evolution, it disproves a form of creationism. The
spontaneous generation that Pasteur and others disproved was the idea
that life forms such as mice, maggots, and bacteria can appear fully
formed. His studies showed that fully-formed organisms do not just
manifest. Pasteur's work disproves a deity creating fully-formed
creatures similarly described in a literal translation in Genesis.
There is no law of biogenesis saying that very primitive life cannot
form from increasingly complex molecules.
Comfort says scientists have tried for years to build even the most simple building block of life, but all have failed.
Ugh, this is very inaccurate. Multiple
studies have shown that organic material and certain materials given
in certain conditions can produce the first building blocks of life.
Miller-Urey experiment did create the
building blocks of life and amino acids. Craig Venter is on the verge
of creating synthetic life.
Comfort quotes Sir Frederick Hoyle on the very low probability of "spontaneous generation."
Apart from appeal to authority|appealing to authority, Comfort continues to assume everything must be "spontaneous" and be fully formed based on his personal presuppositions obtained from a literal translation of the book of Genesis.
On examining the complexity of the cell, Comfort introduces Michael Denton, a intelligent design proponent. Comfort says that there is no evidence of how life could have come into being (which is absolutely not true) but instead are finding examples of complexity that can only be the result of divine intervention.
What Comfort and Michael Denton continue to fail to realize is that the first cell was not as complex as our modern cells (which had billions of years to evolve and modify new parts); in fact they were incredibly simple. The fact that life began with incredibly simple cells and became the complex cells we have today is testament to the reality of evolution.
Chapter 4: The Origin of Species
Comfort brings up several exposed frauds that supposedly proved evolution.
One hoax cannot indicate the inferiority of conventional archeology, because creationists have several of their own, including the Inca Stones, Paluxy footprints, the Calaveras skull, Moab and Malachite Man, and others. More telling is how people deal with these hoaxes. When something is exposed, it stopped being used as evidence. The creationist hoaxes, however, can still be found cited as if they were real.
Comfort brings up Archaeoraptor. Comfort provides a quote from Storrs L. Olson (Curator of Birds at the National Museum of Natural History at the Smithsonian Museum),
"National Geographic has reached an all-time low for engaging in sensationalistic, unsubstantiated, tabloid journalism.... The idea of feathered dinosaurs ... is now fast becoming one of the grander scientific hoaxes of our age."
Only a handful of scientists ever saw Archaeoraptor, but every one who did noted that it was composite piece, and the artistic amateurs who paid for the fossil were repeatedly warned that some parts of it might not even belong to the whole. Popular press foolishly scooped the story prior to peer review, where it was instantly exposed as a fake by multiple experts, and each submission to scientific journals was immediately rejected. Archaeoraptor therefore fooled no one in the scientific community at all. The irony there is that the tail of the alleged Archaeoraptor turned out to belong to the as-yet undiscovered Microraptor, a four-winged and apparently gliding feathered dinosaur which turned out to be even more compelling proof of avian evolution from dinosaurs than Archaeopteryx was in Darwin’s day. The scientific process of peer-review seeks out and exposes fraud by design. But antievolutionist arguments are withheld from peer-review because they are driven entirely by frauds including misstatements, out-of-context quote-mining, and contrived or distorted falsehoods, and terms erroneously redefined into instigative reactionary nonsense unintelligible as anything other than propaganda. In short, if creationists knew how to expose a fraud, they wouldn’t be creationists anymore. It's rather mind-boggling that people can still deny in their minds the existence of feathered dinosaurs. You can walk into any one of many Natural History museums all over the world and see one for yourself! Comfort Comfort claimed to have visited a museum in Paris, but saw no such creatures, meaning he choose not to see or did see but either did not know what he was looking at or decided not to tell his readers. Comfort also mistakes disagreement in science for a crisis. Disagreement is what makes science interesting. Science is progressive.
Comfort moves on to address whale evolution. The first fossil he mentions is Pakicetus, and argues that all the evidence drawn from this a single skull and tells the reader that not a single bone in its body has ever been found.
However, later discoveries had uncovered other complete skeletons of dozens of Pakicetus. Later discoveries showed Pakicetus looked nothing like the original sketched by paleontologists. This however, does nothing to counter the fact that Pakicetus still fits the link between land mammals and whales. Pakicetus rear limbs resemble flippers, but still walked upright.[1] Examining its skull alone tells us much about it. The shape of its skull was definitely cetacean, and its teeth were between the ancestral and modern states.[2] Comfort does not include any of the following links between land mammals and whales: Ambulocetus natans, Indocetus ramani, Dorudon, Basilosaurus, etc.
Comfort argues that same features proves same creator.
However, Comfort provides zero proof of this, nor does he even attempt to show that this creator is his particular god or a bunch of invisible sky pixies. Natural selection is a form of creator and builds up on pre-existing traits, so it is not surprising that later evolved animals will share similar features. Comfort's claim of a common-feature-common-designer cannot be tested and has no predictive power.
Next, he brings up Piltdown Man.
The British museum touted the “Piltdown man” as authentic, but the American Museum of Natural History displayed it only as a “mixture of ape and man fossils”, which is what it eventually turned out to be. There was no way to adequately examine such things back in 1915. Chemical tests –common today- didn’t yet exist and we didn’t yet have a practical understanding of radiation. And before the first australopiths were discovered, we didn’t know exactly what to expect of the links that were then still missing between humans and the other apes known at that time. But as we began filling in the gaps in human evolution with thousands of legitimate fossils, a pattern emerged which left Piltdown an increasingly obvious anomaly. Consequently it was taken off display and stored away almost continuously for decades. It lost importance in most discussions because, in light of everything else we discovered over the next few decades, it just never fit, and was eventually dismissed from the list of potential human ancestors for that reason.
As the years wore on, criticism arose against everyone who ever promoted the Piltdown collection because there seemed to be so much wrong with it. Finally, in the 1950s, it was taken back out of the box and scrutinized via more modern means. First fluorine dating revealed that it was much too recent, and it was shown to have been chemically-treated to give a false impression of its age and mineral composition. Then it was finally determined that the jaw must have come from an orangutan, and that it had been deliberately reshaped with modern tools in a well-crafted and deliberate forgery. No one knows who did it either. And more importantly, why? Errors were already known and previously reported, but few ever suspected fraud because, what would be the motive? Nearly everyone who stood accused was a man of high reputation and credentials. Maybe that was the motive. Maybe Piltdown man was just a joke that had gone too far. But no one was laughing, and they weren’t going to let it happen again.
Comfort moves on to say the horse evolution is entirely fictional. He uses a quote from Boyce Rensberger addressing the fossil record and horses,
"The popularly-told example of horse evolution, suggesting a gradual sequence of changes from four-toed fox-sized creatures living nearly 50 million years ago to today’s much larger one-toed horse, has long been known to be wrong. Instead of gradual change, fossils of each intermediate species appear fully distinct, persist unchanged, and then become extinct. Transitional forms are unknown."
Comfort's dishonesty may know no bounds. This quote, taken out of context, is from a 1980 article about a four-day meeting at the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago attended, so the article says, by 150 scientists and a very few observers. The mechanisms of evolution were discussed at the meeting, but the article focuses on Punctuated equilibrium.
As new fossils were discovered, though, it became clear that the old model of horse evolution was a serious oversimplification. The ancestors of the modern horse were roughly what that series showed, and were clear evidence that evolution had occurred. But it was misleading to portComfort horse evolution in that smooth straight line, for two reasons:
:# First, horse evolution didn't proceed in a straight line. We now know of many other branches of horse evolution. Our familiar Equus is merely one twig on a once-flourishing bush of equine species. We only have the illusion of straight-line evolution because Equus is the only twig that survived. (See Gould's essay "Life's Little Joke" in Bully for Brontosaurus for more on this topic.)
:# Second, horse evolution was not smooth and gradual. Different traits evolved at different rates, didn't always evolve together, and occasionally reversed "direction". Also, horse species did not always come into being by gradual transformation ("anagenesis") of their ancestors; instead, sometimes new species "split off" from ancestors ("cladogenesis") and then co-existed with those ancestors for some time. Some species arose gradually, others suddenly.
Overall, the horse family demonstrates the diversity of evolutionary mechanisms, and it would be misleading -- and would be a real pity -- to reduce it to an oversimplified straight-line diagram.
Near the end, Comfort returns to his apologetic preaching tactics and playing with peoples fears instead of relying on actual empirical proof (so much for being scientific Comfort). He uses his tactic of are you a good person? and using the Ten Commandments. After questioning, based on God's standards, if you will be guilty or not, Comfort brings up recent polls that a majority of Americans think Hell is real.
However, reality is not altered by popular vote. There still remains not a shred of proof of such a place like hell.
Comfort says Hell is a rightful place for people like Hitler. Comfort warns us that God also judges our thought life (greed, selflessness, pride, lust, hatred, etc.) Comfort asks if the reader is concerned about their fate and are probably trying to figure out which religion to choose. Comfort says he will explain why you should pick Christianity in the next chapter.
The problem with this line of thinking is that Comfort first sets up a scenario that traps everyone and makes nobody innocent, and then provides a method of salvation that '''only''' his narrow version of God can give. Basically, he is just providing the readers with snake oil.
Chapter 5: Mutant Turtles
This chapter is mostly about mutants with very little to do with turtles. The only time Comfort mentions turtles is to question where are the transitional fossils for turtles.
He claims there are none, but this is not true.
There is Odontochelys semistestacea, a toothed (unlike toothless modern turtles) proto-turtle with a plastron (belly armor) but no shell on its back (to be sure, it is possible that this represents the secondary loss of an already-evolved upper shell), but transitional fossils leading up to true turtles are still rare. This does not, of course, make those australopiths and early hominines, whales with hind legs and small heads, feathered theropods, genetics, ERVs, etc. go away. Remember, gaps are expected to be in the fossil record, but already the fossil record is very rich and transitional fossils are still being uncovered by the bush full.
Ray also briefly discusses vestigial organs, dismissing them as evidence for evolution on the grounds that they represent a loss rather than a gain of information, and because it can never be demonstrated conclusively that a vestige has no function.
However, "Vestigial" does not mean an organ is useless. A vestige is a "trace or visible sign left by something lost or vanished."
Most of the chapter is about why mutations do not enable one "kind" to evolve into another. Ray spends a surprising number of lines and quote-mines to argue that mutations are random (this is in connection with a misunderstanding of punctuated equilibria, which Ray apparently thinks means that environmental pressures can cause a lizard to lay an egg that hatches out into a robin). That's not how he puts it; he argues that mutations exist before the environmental conditions that select for or against them, and do not arise in response to need, but then, that's more or less what "random mutations" means.
He offers no dissent from the view that mutations occur, that they occur frequently, and that a few of them are beneficial, and that different mutations are beneficial in different environments. So we may take Ray as conceding that mutations occur and can be, on rare occasions, beneficial.
Ray argues that mutations do not "add information." For the sake of argument, he says even if they do, this added information cannot accumulate to produce novel organs, structures, and abilities.
Ray is not nearly so clear on what "added information" actually would be, or how one would determine or compare the information content of a gene as he is that whatever information is, mutations cannot create it. We have seen mutations give rise to new abilities. For example we’ve identified an emerging population of tetrachromatic women who can see a bit of the normally invisible ultraviolet spectrum. Another example is the CCR5-delta 32 mutation. About 10% of whites of European origin now carry it. But the incidence is only 2% in central Asia, and is completely absent among East Asians, Africans, and tribal Americans. It appears to have suddenly become relatively common among white Europeans about 700 years ago, evidently as a result of the Black Plague, indicating another example of natural selection allowing one gene dominance in a changing environment. It is harmless or neutral in every respect other than its one clearly beneficial feature. According to Science-Frontiers.com, if one inherits this gene from both parents, they will be especially resistant, if not immune to AIDS.
Mutations are degrees of variation which are usually quite subtle but cumulative, normally harmless, and occasionally advantageous. Any change in information is different information, not already present, and therefore can only be considered “new”. But of the many types of mutations known to occur, there are additions and duplications as well as deletions and the rest. So yes, genetic material can be added or taken away. But as to whether “information” has been added as opposed to lost, we can’t really tell because creationists won’t tell us what they think “information” is or how to measure it. They’ll readily state (as if it had somehow been confirmed) that it takes more "information" to make a bird than it does a dinosaur, but if you ask 'em how much more, they’ll shut right up.
Ray goes on but provides several quote mines, including one from Francisco Ayala (a strong a critic of creationism and the intelligent design movement) to make the appearance Ayala think that mutations cannot accumulate into new structures. Ray concludes that even if mutations add information, this added information can't keep accumulating into a new structure. What use, Comfort asks (quoting Stephen Gould) would two percent of a wing be? Scientific-illiterate Ray describes a 2% wing as a tiny, useless stub sticking out of the side of a bird that provides zero help for flight.
What is 2% of a wing? One might be inclined to start with coelurosaurs, and see that 2% wing in the arm of something like the down-covered forelimb of Sinosauropteryx: in this case, that two percent would be an insulated, grasping or climbing arm. It would not work as a wing, but it would work as a forelimb suitable for a warm-blooded predator. A 20% arm would be something with more complete feathers, used for display, to look larger and more threatening or to impress potential mates, and a 50% wing (say, something like the fore- and hind limbs of Microraptor) would be useful for gliding (analogous to the "half-formed wings" of flying squirrels).
Chapter 6: Science and Atheism
Comfort repeats the fallacious fine-tuning argument, abiogenesis and evolution is impossible.
The evidence does not agree with Ray Comfort.
Ray asserts that there is no evidence to support evolution.
He may be right, if the following did not exist: transitional fossils, comparative anatomy, comparative genomics, ERVs, pseudogenes, biogeography, ontology, phylogeny, and so on and so on. Ray goes on to use the Law of Biogenesis to counter evolution, which permits Brussels sprouts and cauliflower to be bred from the same species, somehow prevents changes from accumulating enough to transgress the nebulous boundaries around "created kinds."
Comfort quote mines Stephen J. Gould that Homo sapiens is a "glorious accident."
Ray goes on to question the chances of evolution, that is that everything had to have happened at the right times.
This is a long debunked argument that is still favored by creationists.
The rest of the chapter consists of bringing up smart people who believed in God.
Fallacy known as argument ad populum - if all these smart people also believed the earth was flat, that does not make it so.
Ray asserts that science cannot contradict Christianity, since science arose in a Christian culture, and that faith itself cannot be a problem, since since we all have faith in something, whether God or human reason.
Lets address both parts,
1) As many scholars and historians would point out, Christianity was not responsible for the blossom of science. Science predates Christianity, back to the ancient Greeks (who were pagans).
2) Faith" in the working of your computer or your car or your logic is not the same thing as "faith" that some collection of ancient writings simply must be self-consistent and inerrant, and that any evidence to the contrary must be fake or misunderstood. Ray tries to ask us to give up faith in mere humans for faith in humans' infallible Creator, but he must end up asking us to keep that faith in mere humans, and add to it faith in a set of ideas compiled and interpreted by more mere humans.
Chapter 7: Evolution's Strange Dilemma
Ray begins by pointing out that humans are widely religious; the overwhelming majority of humans today and historically accept not only that they were designed but that the Designer has (or designers have) a personal interest in them. If, Ray asks, evolution is supposed to have shaped our minds to grasp and deal with reality, why is there such widespread acceptance of god? Something that atheists insist is not real and has no real evidence? If evolution has shaped our faculties for purposes -- if we hunger because we need food, and food exists, and we feel thirsty because we need water and water exists, and we feel sexual desire because we need sex to reproduce (and it exists), then ought we not consider, indeed embrace, the idea that we (many of us, anyway) feel a need for God because God exists and we really need Him?
This is not much a dilemma at all, since evolutionists have proposed various explanations for religion.[1] Religions themselves evolve, including Christianity.
Ray notes that even surviving stone-age tribes accept that murder and theft and adultery are bad. Why, he asks, are humans uniquely and (almost) universally moral animals? He argues that without a Creator, we have no basis for absolute morals, so a moral nature is further evidence for a Creator.
However, morality comes from within humanity through evolution. A moral sense is something shaped by natural selection to enable us to live in groups and cooperate for mutual benefit. How does a Creator provide a basis for absolute morality? Here is a real dilemma Ray: Euthyphro dilemma. Does God say something is evil because he says so, or does he say it is evil simply because it is evil? Plus, if the Bible does provide an absolute objective moral system, where is it? Why cant genuine Christians agree on certain issues or agree what God thinks and what he wants?
Wont bother trying to refute it here, just click the given link to read a detailed rebuttal.
Chapter 8: The Four Gifts
Ray begins this chapter presuming the reader believes in God and know that they will be judged. Ray then uses his parachute analogy, that is that if you were in a plane that was going down and people offered you a variety of gifts, you would reject them. However, when someone offers you a parachute, you take it and put your trust in it to save your life. He compares this parachute with faith in Jesus Christ.
This however, is an flawed argument known as Pascal's Wager. Ray Comfort says his parachute (provided by his invisible friend) is safe and harmless, but suddenly another passenger tells you "Don't use his parachute, it has holes in it. Use mine provided by my invisible friend." Then a third passenger announces “My invisible friend slashed all the parachutes on board. He takes care of his chosen people, and as none of you were born into the correct lineage, it’s too bad for you.” Some people refuse parachutes and urge others to do the same, because it would interfere with the master plan of the father of their invisible friend (these are the same people who refuse medical care in favor of prayer and faith healing). The drama goes on with the rest of the passengers, until you demand to actually see proof of a doomed plane and which parachute does work. Some say you must not demand for evidence and just have faith. Regardless, you inspect the plane and the parachutes. The plane is operating just fine in every way and each parachute has holes in them big enough you can fit your head through them. Some of the parachutes terribly constrict people, harming them. The plane reaches its destination safely, but the drama continues through the terminal, security, all the way out beyond the airport. You learn from airports around the world that many people have harmed many others and themselves due to their faith in their parachute provided by their particular invisible friend.
Chapter 9: Three Wise Fools
If you were expecting this chapter to include names of humans greatest thinkers, too bad. Instead, Ray creates three skeptics just like Ray created Mr. Joe Average in the first chapter.
These three skeptics are on their way to see a test of electricity. These skeptics do not "believe" in electric power because they cannot observe it. Even when they see a switched turned and a light bulb turned on, they still do not accept it because they find some apparent errors in a biographical sketch of Thomas Edison provided by the power company, and because electricity has been used to kill animals and people. They will not make the simple test to see if electricity is real.
What Ray is doing here is saying that skeptics will not "test" Christianity by actually believing and repenting. How does he know many skeptics have already done that? It seems the only way to impress Ray Comfort is that we have to "know" God. How do we know what we experience is not just a product of our minds. Michael Harner, and anthropologist who lived among the Jivaro Indians of the Ecuadoran Amazon, described his experience with ayahuasca as follows:
“For several hours after drinking the brew, I found myself although awake, in a world literally beyond my wildest dreams. I met bird-like people, as well as a dragon-like creature who explained they were the true Gods of this world. I enlisted the services of other spirit helpers in attempting to fly through the far reaches of the Galaxy.”
There a literally hundreds or thousands of these reported events that certain drugs, seizures, stimulations, rituals, etc. all can produce feelings and connections with higher powers.
Also, about the electric company, there's the fact that the power company makes no claims that using electricity will make you a kinder, gentler person, or that "true electricity" can never be used for bad ends, or even that its brochures are completely inerrant. If electricity can be used to murder and to execute murderers, that has no bearing whatsoever on the reality of electricity or the truth of the power company's claims. But if Christianity does not change believers' lives -- or if it does, but there are so few true believers that they get lost in the masses of false converts -- that has rather more bearing on the claims Christianity makes for itself.
Ray ends this chapter with a repeat of Pascal's Wager, reminding us that 10 out of 10 people die and we should embrace our fear of death and accept Christ.
Ray still hasn't demonstrated that his parachutes work and rival electric company's don't, or that the Bible's threats of Hell are more credible than the Koran's.
Chapter 10: This Day Was Different
In this chapter, Ray tries to argue that the Bible is clearly of supernatural origin, and hence further proof of God, and that the Bible is not actually necessary in order to know God and be saved.
Ray offers two main lines of evidence for the supernatural inspiration of the scriptural text, knowledge of creation (nature) and knowledge of the future (prophecies).
Ray insists, in the section of this chapter, that "the scriptures tell us that the Earth is round ... not flat or square."
But it obviously didn't tell Josephus, or the author of Enoch, or Lactantius Firmianus, or Theophilus of Antioch, that the Earth was a sphere. Ray says science of the day taught the earth was flat, but this is demonstrably false. Ancient Greeks calculated that the earth was spherical, such as Pythagoras in the fifth century BCE. He figured out that the Earth is a sphere without divine inspiration and with no technology not available centuries earlier; even if the Bible did clearly state that the Earth was a sphere, it would not be knowledge that proved supernatural inspiration.
Ray also interprets Hebrews 11:3 as referring to atoms.
While this would not, in itself, be astonishing (the pagan philosopher Democritus had proposed atomism four centuries earlier, and it was part of the Epicurean philosophy that is mentioned in the Bible), Ray's interpretation would imply that Christians knew by faith what Epicureans believed by human reason or speculation, which seems an odd interpretation, especially in light of the Church's long suspicion of atomism.
As for prophecies, none of the ones presented are accurate or true. Many of them are fake/imaginary prophecies or unfulfilled prophecies[1] There are several mundane ways in which a prediction of the future can be fulfilled:
Retrodiction. The "prophecy" can be written or modified after the events fulfilling it have already occurred.
Vagueness. The prophecy can be worded in such a way that people can
interpret any outcome as a fulfillment. Nostradomus's prophecies are all
of this type. Vagueness works particularly well when people are
religiously motivated to believe the prophecies.
Inevitability. The prophecy can predict something that is almost sure to
happen, such as the collapse of a city. Since nothing lasts forever,
the city is sure to fall someday. If it has not, it can be said that
according to prophecy, it will.
Denial. One can claim that the fulfilling events occurred even if they
have not. Or, more commonly, one can forget that the prophecy was ever
made.
Self-fulfillment. A person can act deliberately to satisfy a known prophecy.
There are no prophecies in the Bible that cannot easily fit into one or more of those categories.
In conclusion, Ray argues that we all have seen the evidence of Gods existence through creation, conscience, and conversion. Ray notes the Bible is not the whole source of conversion, since the early Christians did not have a complete form of the New Testament.
Chapter 11: Alleged Mistakes in the Bible
In this chapter, Ray tries to explain away the seeming contradictions in the Bible and counter claims by non-believers why the Bible should not be trusted. He says that God put is these contradictions to "snare" non-believers.
As we will see, Ray desperately pulled this feeble excuse out of the air.
Ray says that all Christians believe Scripture is God inspired, citing 2 Timothy 3:16.
What Ray does not share with the reader is that 2 Timothy, along with many other NT books, is considered by a vast majority of critical scholars to be pseudepigraphical, that is it was not written by Paul but by a forger. That is right, forgers have made it into the word of God.
Comfort explains the creation of Adam, consisting of three parts: the boy, soul, and spirit. Ray claims atheists have a soul, but no spirit and thus cannot understand God. He compares them to fish in the ocean who do not know they are surrounded by water.
Ray ignores the vast amount of study that shows the evolution of the conscious. Ray says our soul is the part of our bodies that produces emotions, will, and conscience. Actually, our emotions are produced in the limbic system of our brains, not a trace of a supernatural immaterial being required for it to function.
Ray says that Adam died spiritually when he sinned and God removed his Spirit from Adam. And thus, all of Adam's descendants would be spiritually dead, because according to Ray, everything produces after its own "kind" - but he never explains what kind means.
In fact, Ray Comfort uses the word "kind" to mean whatever he wants at any given time. It can mean "species" at one moment, and then it can mean Genus, or even later as Kingdom.
Here's the proof,
Lot's Stupidity
Deuteronomy 25:11, 12. Ray cites this as proof brought forth by atheists to show the Bible cannot be trusted. It tells of a woman defending her husband, and if she should touch the attackers genitals then her hand must be cut off. Ray says this type of incident has not been found anywhere is Scripture. It may not have happened in ''Scripture'' but actually happened in real life, otherwise there would be no point of including this rule if it did not happen. Ray says that the Bible does not ''literally'' men cut off your arm. Mark 5:30 says the same, but Ray says it is not to be taken literally.
The early christian fathers would disagree. Some actually cut off their hand and demanded their subjects to do the same. Christian father Origen castrated himself and said his followers should do the same.
Next, Ray includes the story of Lot handing his own daughters to a crowd so they can rape them. Ray says the Scriptures are instructions, so he says do not offer your daughters up to a crowd.
Ray avoided the issue at hand, the fact Lot did offer his daughters, and if the Scripture is a set of instructions, then indeed the Bible promotes giving away your daughters.
Finally, Ray points out atheists objections to the food laws in Leviticus. Ray says the purpose of this was to separate the Israelites apart from their neighbors to keep the Israelites "pure."
He provides no reference of the practices and beliefs of the pagans. Also, do you know what else was set in law to keep the Israelites pure: supernatural miscarriages (Numbers 5)
Ray admits things may seem contradictory, when taken out of context. These verses are not taken out of context, they are there for all to read. Ray settles that if such a confusion is found, he must decide to doubt or trust in God.
Of course, he chooses trust, or have blind faith in a book of contradictions.
A Nearsighted View
Comfort compares atheists to a nearsighted person looking at the Mona Lisa, that they cannot see the beauty and meaning of the whole picture. Here, he provides 12 examples of biblical contradictions presented by atheists to distrust the Bible.
Only 12? Of course, Ray is cherry-picking the simplest contradictions. People have written novels of confirmed contradictions and discrepancies in the Bible (like ''The Bible Against Itself'' by Randel McCraw Helms) and websites display an entire list of contradictions.[1] [2] The Bible contains hundreds of contradictions and many inconsistencies and discrepancies.[3]
2) Proverbs 3:13;4:7-10;19:8 and 1 Corinthians 1:19-21. Ray says Proverbs speak of wisdom coming from God, whereas Corinthians compares wisdom from God and wisdom from the "foolish world." Regardless, this is god proclaiming to destroy wisdom. Earlier in 1 Corinthians, it says preaching the cross would appear foolish to the wise (the wise God encourages in proverbs).
This does not make sense and is clearly contradictory.
3) Numbers 15:24-28 and Hebrews 10:11. Ray says that the sacrifices in Numbers cannot provide perfect atonement, whereas Hebrews tells of the sacrifice of Jesus makes believers perfect in the eyes of God.
This does not solve the problem. Atonement is atonement, and it shall be forgiven. Leviticus 6:7 further explains "''And the priest shall make an atonement for him before the Lord: and it shall be forgiven him.''" So the sacrifice of Jesus is not entirely necessary.
4) Exodus 20:8-11;31:15-17;35:1-3 and Romans 14:5; Colossians 2:14-16
5) Matthew 5:43,44;22:39 and Matthew 10:5
8) Deuteronomy 23:1 and Matthew 19:12
11) Psalm 30:5; Jeremiah 3:12; Micah 7:18 and Jeremiah 17:4; Matthew 25:46
12) Psalm 78:69; Ecclesiastics 1:4;3:14 and Psalm 102:25; Matthew 24:35; Mark 13:31; Luke 21:33; Hebrews 1:10,11; 2 Peter 3:10.
What Ray does not share is that 2 Peter is unanimously considered to be pseudonymous (that is, written by a forger).
Chapter 12: Common Objections to Christianity
What about suffering - doesn't that prove there isn't a loving God?
Ray addresses this by telling the reader to examine the soil producing weeds.
????
How can you love the God when the Bible encourages slavery?
Ray says the Bible acknowledges slavery. Comfort says that the Laws of the Old Testament was not confined to slaves but to Israel, the Law for death was for blasphemers, adultery, homosexuality, rape, etc.
Finally, Ray says people obey the law when "there is a bite to it." He says murderers get free lunch, TV, gym hours, and such for many years. Ray says no wonder there were several hundred thousand murders in America in the 1990's.
Actually, it does more than that; Exodus 21 goes into great detail of how to treat your slave. Jesus Christ, the perfect moral savior, never denounced slavery once.
Ray goes on to argue that slaves back then were like modern day servants. He does not say what type of servant, like a housekeeper? Comfort says slave in the New Testament meant "bondservant" but does not provide any reference or scholar work about this.
The Bible says children should be stoned to death
Ray says that the law says parents of a drunk, rebellious youth had the option to take them to the elders to decide to stone them or not. Ray concludes this never happened because it is not mentioned again in Scripture.
Comfort just dances around the problem: the Bible says children should be stoned to death. This is the perfect moral system of God? If you child is caught sneaking several brews, you take him to a non-family stranger with a holy book to decide their fate? This is similar to a story that happened in Africa: a mother locked up her own daughter in a closet for nine years without food or water because her pastor told her that her child was a witch. Honestly, if none of these people were religious or superstitious, this pain and suffering could have been completely avoided. And there is the problem of death. Why kill these youths just for being drunk or rebellious? Why not set a program to get them sober? No, the God of the Bible demands death.
What kind of God would tell Joshua to kill the Canaanites - every man, woman, and child?
Ray tries to counter this with a story about his father leaving him each day to fend for himself while his father went to kill animals to provide food and shelter for them.
The problem with this is, we are not comparing God to a mortal man. God is God, and does not have to leave to make money.
Ray acknowledges that bits of the bible can portray God as a tyrant, but Ray implored the readers to think about what God has done for you (gave you life and your senses, etc).
Hitler was a Christian!
Here, Ray says that Hitler was brought up in a Roman Catholic background, but Ray says he later developed an anti-Christian worldview and believed in evolution.
That is not true, Hitler never accepted Darwin's theory of evolution. Hitler remained a Christian creationist (Ray Comfort's camp).
Hitler was not an anti-Christian. He supported and encourage the production of Christian churches and programs. He was clearly not an evolutionist. The only time he ever mentioned Darwin in his books or speeches is to slam Darwin and promote creationism.
"Hence today I believe that I am acting in accordance with the will of the Almighty Creator: by defending myself against the Jew, I am fighting for the work of the Lord" (Hitler 1943, 65).
The Nazi Party in general rejected Darwinism and supported Christianity. In 1935, Die Bücherei, the official Nazi journal for lending libraries, published a list of guidelines of works to reject, including: Writings of a philosophical and social nature whose content deals with the false scientific enlightenment of primitive Darwinism and Monism (Häckel). (Die Bücherei 1935, 279)
What about Galileo - didn't the church persecute him?
Ray says Galileo had the audacity to question what ''science'' believed of the day: [[geocentrism]]. Ray says that Galileo's scientific ''beliefs'' did not contradiction scripture, but contradicted the Roman Catholic Church and science of the day.
This is a flat out lie, Ray is simply trying to rewrite history. Science did not teach the earth was flat, scripture did. Also, Galileo's scientific discoveries were not mere beliefs, but observable fact.
The Church is full of hypocrites
Ray says hypocrites may show up in church every Sunday, but there are no hypocrites in the church of Christ's body (what does that mean?).
Jesus Christ never existed
Ray says the entire New Testament is a historical record that confirms his existence and there is proof that a man named Jesus of Nazareth existed in the first century.
Actually, the historicity of Jesus disagrees. There is very little or no historical evidence to support Jesus. The New testament is not a historical document, it is full of flaws and written by unknown authors who never eye-witnessed Jesus.
Ray says that over 25,000 archaeological discoveries show the accuracy of the Bible.
Unfortunately, the evidence for veracity of the settings of the New Testament - and Old Testament - is so bad that scholars now question the whole model of "biblical archaeology," which starts with the assumption that the Bible is a reliable guide for field research. There is now so much archaeological evidence against the historical accuracy of the Bible that the term "biblical archaeology" has been discarded by professional archaeologists and "Syro-Palestinian archaeology" has been suggested by some in the field as a more appropriate term. Furthermore, Homer's Odyssey describes the travels of Odysseus throughout the Greek islands. The epic describes, in detail, many locations that existed in history. But should we take Odysseus, the Greek gods and goddesses, one-eyed giants and monsters as literal fact simply because the story depicts geographic locations accurately? Of course not.
Ray then lists several secular sources: Josephus, the Babylonian Talmud, Pliny the Younger, Tacticus, etc.
However, all of these supposed evidences have been critically examined by many scholars. None of the above evidences provide sufficient evidence for the historicity of Jesus. None of the given sources were even alive during the time of Jesus, all the historians of the time who were alive never mention Jesus once.
Chapter 13: Confessions of a Rocket Scientist
Comfort passes the pen to a scientist, an engineer who makes the claim that everything must be created, because scientists discover that which exists while engineers create that which never did. He believes God is an engineer. However, engineers do not create new things from nothing, and this "rocket science" will be unable to prove it.
If the anonymous engineer makes a statement like "everything must be created" then that means that god must have a creator. if the engineer and/or Ray Comfort says "nuh-ah" then obviously not everything needs to be created.
Before allowing the scientist to make a case, Comfort argues for three "evidences for the existence of God."
*Creation. Using a coca-cola can as an example, Ray "theorizes" the origin of the can came from billions of years ago, when there was an unexplainable massive explosion in space, and from it came a rock and on the rock was a brown bubbling pool where after millions of years, aluminum came forth and created itself a tab on the top. Millions of years later, red and white paint fell from the sky and formed the words on the coca-cola can. Ray Comfort claims that if you find something that was created, there must be a creator. He claims that a building must have a builder and a painting must have a painter, even though you cannot see, touch, smell, hear, or taste him. This to Comfort is scientific proof of a creator and does not require faith to believe in a creator. According to Ray, all you need is eyes that can see and a brain works. Ray asks himself "can we scientifically prove that a painting had a painter?" He replies if we put a dozen scientists in a room with a painting, they will all answer that it indeed had a painter. Ray includes nothing more. He then says the human body is a very complex machine and the eye is perfect so there must be a designer. He then addresses those who are not convinced by his arguments as people who put themselves on an "intellectual pedestal."
Ray simply does not understand the word "theory," misleading the audience. His argument is of course a logical fallacy: anything that exists, simply because it exists, must have been deliberately created by an intelligent being for an intended purpose. By his logic, does lightning have a lightning maker? His argument also includes an argument from design fallacy. We see design and beauty in snowflakes and crystals, but we also know they form under natural causes without invoking the supernatural. As Brian will point out, we can actually test if a painting had a painter and we could verify who it is and how they did it, but we cannot do so with God. And that is where Ray fails, who claimed that he would be able to prove the existence of God scientifically. Also, Ray builds an absurd straw man of the Big Bang Theory, abiogenesis, and evolution and falsely thinks that disproving them makes creation win by default. He also tries to mock the intellect and present an ad hominem towards those who don't believe in God by implying that their eyes and brains must not be functional. He insults skeptics as putting themselves on a pedestal, basically Ray's arguments are so feeble that they are simply comical and do not require a lot of thought to see through it, and that is why Ray attacks the intellectual and trying to prevent the audience from thinking to deeply into things.
*Conscience. According to Ray, God put within each of us conscience when God made us in his image. This separates us from the other animals since we have the ability to know right from wrong. But, according to Ray, our conscience has "lost its life on the outside" and each of us are "self-admitted blaspheming, lying, thieving, adulterers at heart" and could only be restored by the Ten Commandments. He then goes on using his old tactic of "are you a good person?" In this speech, Ray very briefly tells the audience that he may sound preachy, but the gospel is the greatest evidence for God anyone could have.
This of course is based on ignorance of science (zoology, sociology, evolution). All societal species (including humans) have a sense of compassion and community amongst their kinsmen, friends and fellows which - in many species - leads to acts of devotion, defense, and even self-sacrifice on their behalf.
*Conversion According to Ray, if you believe in God and seek him out, you will find him and you will experience Jesus. "That is the ultimate proof" -Ray Comfort.
What Comfort failed to understand was the same result can be achieved for those who seek out ghosts, aliens, Bigfoot, or any deity "with their whole heart", meaning they have already assumed these things exist without question or prior evidence that they exist in the first place.
The scientist addresses the Big Bang Theory. He argues if the Big Bang were true, basing it on his assumption that the Big Bang says everything was spinning and then separated, that all planets and galaxies should be spinning the same direction, not in different directions. He claims that this theory is ridiculous, and yet scientific people have the gal to ridicule those who believe in God.
However, Ray straw-mans the Big Bang. It does not claim that everything was spinning. The big bang is quite a different subject from the formation of solar systems. Rotations within the universe are not expected to be related to any rotation of the cosmos. Galaxies probably arose from slightly denser regions of the early universe, which coalesced and combined due to gravitational and viscous interactions. Since these early density fluctuations were apparently random, we expect galaxies to have random orientations. Solar systems within galaxies have still different origins and additional random influences on their orientations. Conservation of angular momentum doesn't require that everything spin the same way. It requires that a change in spin in one object be compensated for by an opposite change in spin in one or more other objects. Retrograde planets are not a violation of angular momentum because other bodies in the early solar system could account for the compensating spin.
In a section, the scientists says "Despite the fact that the Bible was apparently written by mere men, so were all of my science texts."
Here, he admits the the Bible was written by man, he does not mention God. The difference is that the science texts are written by people who test and proved their claims, unlike the authors of the Bible who relied on superstition and blind faith to make up stories. All the scientists in the past have made breakthroughs based on the scientific method, not biblical revelation.
Next, he claims that the scientific method cannot invalidate the claims made in the Bible, it is perfect because it is written by a perfect being.
Very wrong mate. The Bible is far from perfect, and thus making God imperfect (if it even existed).
The scientist says that he received a Masters of Science Degree in Aerospace Engineering, and came to the conclusion that creation requires a creator. He claimed to be seeking out truth, and found it in scripture.
Apparently, we can only take this anonymous person's word for it, but given Ray's track record of deliberate deception, perhaps this person is just a fictional creation of Ray Comfort.
Chapter 14: Why Bother?
Ray does not repeat the "evidences" for God, he just warns the readers how important their decision of where they would spend eternity is. Ray says the Bible provides an accurate warning and reason why we all deserve hell.
As we have seen, the Bible nor Ray Comfort does not provide us with any reason at all to adopt Christianity.
Ray deals with the passage in Deuteronomy 25:11-12, which prescribes that if a wife tries to rescue her husband from someone he's fighting by squeezing the other man's testicles, her hand must be cut off. Ray suggests that this passage is, like Jesus' command to pluck out our eyes if they tempt us to sin, is hyperbole, not literal prescription.
And of course on his blog, if not in this book, Ray has insisted that, e.g. biblical references to the "windows of the sky" are purely figurative. So technically, he's suggesting that not only is our only safe course to assume that the Bible is literally accurate, but to assume that "Hell" refers to an eternal conscious existence in an eternal lake of fire, even when it might speak figuratively.
Here are the "proofs" Ray provided throughout this book
1. First Cause argument: the Universe cannot come from nothing, and hence must come from an Intelligent Creator.
If something cannot come from nothing, then where did the Intelligent Creator come from. Ignoring that Ray cannot empirically prove the Creator is his narrow version of God, if the answer to the previous question is "he is eternal" then why can't the universe be eternal? Occam's Razor would favor the non-created universe.
2. Design argument: no explanation exists or is possible for the mechanisms of life or the diversity and complexity of living things, except an Intelligent Designer.
Simply wrong. Natural selection is the ''only'' explanation with evidence for the complexity and diversity of life. There is no evidence, however, for an Intelligent Designer. In fact, this argument can be turned on its head when you examine nature and see how ''unintelligently'' designed it has.
3. Argument from General Human Experience: human beings agree that some things are right and others wrong, that human beings don't live up to their own moral standards, and that human beings want something that can't be found in this world.
Not all humans agree what is exactly right or wrong. Human beings do indeed live up to their moral standards, most likely they reflect that of the laws of their culture. The last bit is an absolute claim with zero proof, there can always be a single to a million human beings who don't seek something beyond this world.
4. Argument from specific Christian experience: True Christians know God personally, and you can too if you believe.
Ray and other Christians ''do not'' know anything if their God exists or not. Knowledge can be measured and demonstrated. If you cannot demonstrate it, then you do not know it. Ray provides no model or method to show how accurate or truthful Jesus was in comparison with other biblical, pagan, or mythological figures. Ray did not provide any proof or supporting evidence for the Resurrection of Jesus, but it does not seem to matter to Ray. What seems to really matter is personal experience, which dictates what religion he will believe.
5. Argument from Biblical Information: The Bible contains facts about nature and about future events that was not naturally accessible to humans at the time it was written.
Simply incorrect. As already shown in this book review, his "facts' found in the Bible are not facts at all.
6. Pascal's Wager: Ten out of ten people die, and most of them don't want to. Let your fear of death humble your pride so that you can believe and repent.
Pascal's Wager is a flawed argument. If Ray is worried about the afterlife, then there theoretically there are an infinite number of deities and Ray's chances of being right are near absolute zero. Read my blog "Tackling Pascal's Wager" that explains why that is.
There includes a dialogue between Todd Friel and a person named Jess.
Basically Friel uses the same material as presented in this book.
Ray is glad we picked up this book and read it.
Why thank you Ray, we were overjoyed having to smell the crap you were spewing throughout every page. But Ray does not stop there, he encourages us to read the Bible and get to know God.
Ray ends this chapter with sharing his experience with Kirk Cameron filming an episode. After the filming, Ray decided to ride a bull. He held onto the bull by the horns. Ray calls himself am "intelligent, clear-thinking human being" however as we have seen throughout this book review that is certainly not true. He compares being "gored" by the bull and confronting atheists. Ray retells his motivation for spreading the gospel: Hell is real and people are going there. He encourages Christians to take the bull by the horns, confront the lost and sinned with Christian love and spread the gospel.